Whenever
gunmen kill expatriate workers in Saudi Arabia, they set off
alarm bells in international oil markets. But louder bells
should be ringing throughout the Muslim world over the cost
to Islam of the ongoing conflict between the Saudi royal
family and the Wahhabi zealots it helped create and who now
vow to overthrow it.
In
late May, militants launched two audacious attacks against
foreign oil workers, killing seven in Yanbu on Saudi
Arabia's west coast and 22 in the oil-rich Eastern Province.
At least three foreigners have been killed in the past week
alone, and an American, Paul Marshall Johnson, has been
abducted, apparently by Al-Qaeda.
Of
all the countries in the region where governments have
struggled to put down militants, Saudi Arabia is the most
pivotal, and not just because it can determine the next
emergency OPEC meeting. Islam was born in what is now Saudi
Arabia. King Fahd is referred to as the "Custodian of the
Two Holy Mosques" of Mecca and Medina, which millions of
Muslim pilgrims visit every year. If oil has been Saudi
Arabia's trump card on the international stage, then Islam
has given it plenty of prestige on the Muslim one.
So
when the gunmen who recently took over a housing complex in
Khobar told terrified foreign oil workers that they were
looking for "infidels" during an hours-long shooting spree
that left 22 dead, including a 10-year-old Egyptian
schoolboy, and claimed that it was in the name of Islam that
they dragged the corpse of a 62-year-old Briton through the
streets and slit the throats of nine hostages, the Muslim
world cannot remain silent.
It
is long past the time when Muslims should have questioned
the puritanical Wahhabi ideology prevailing in Saudi Arabia,
and which is pulling the rug out from under Saudi life. For
this is the same ideology that militant movements have
adopted for years throughout the Muslim world.
For one small but recent example one need look no further
than Saudi Arabia's neighbor, Iraq. Recent press reports
suggest that the town of Fallujah has turned into an Islamic
mini-state - anyone caught selling alcohol is liable to be
flogged and paraded throughout the city; men are encouraged
to grow beards and barbers are warned against giving
"Western" hair cuts; women rarely appear in public, and when
they do they are covered from head to toe.
The men enforcing this alleged public piety bear an
uncomfortable resemblance to Saudi Arabia's mutawwaiin, or
morality police - officers of the Kafkaesque-sounding
Committee for the Promotion of Virtue and the Prevention of
Vice. The best way to describe the mutawwaiin is to consider
them the godfathers of the Taleban. It is the Wahhabi
ideology of the mutawwaiin that gave birth to the Taleban
and the misery they unleashed on the people of Afghanistan.
That same misery seems to be taking hold in Fallujah.
While there is little doubt that the Israeli occupation of
the West Bank and Gaza, and now the American occupation of
Iraq, fuel many a militant's fire in the Middle East,
Wahhabi Islam can be found in most of the embers.
I
lived in Saudi Arabia for six years in the 1980s and know
how all-pervasive Wahhabism is. It was on posters lining the
corridors of my women-only university showing how a "good
Muslim woman" should dress - in black from head to toe - and
it made sure that gender apartheid kept those same good
Muslim women in the back two rows of public buses. It was in
shopping malls patrolled by mutawwaiin ready to arrest
shopkeepers who didn't close their stores for prayer time.
And it was in the grim Friday news tallies of the day's
public beheadings.
And it is still there today in the matters occupying the
time of Saudi clerics. Two weeks before the Khobar rampage,
a Saudi friend forwarded me a copy of a fatwa, or religious
ruling, issued by senior clerics. The fatwa banned the
giving of flowers when visiting the sick in the hospital.
The ruling observed: "It is not the habit of Muslims to
offer flowers to the sick in hospital. This is a custom
imported from the land of the infidels by those whose faith
is weak. Therefore it is not permitted to deal with flowers
in this way, whether to sell them, buy them or offer them as
gifts."
Wahhabi militants operate in that great chasm between a
mindset that bans the giving of flowers to the sick and life
as we know it at the start of the 21st century. Osama bin
Laden may be Wahhabism's most recognizable face, but the
ideology does not lack for followers or for hatred, and not
just directed against "infidels" - women and non-Wahhabis
are equally disparaged.
The Saudi royal family has its own reckoning with Wahhabism.
It took suicide bombings in Riyadh last year for the
government to finally acknowledge the existence of homegrown
extremism, but the rest of us gained no satisfaction from
saying that it was only a case of the chickens coming home
to roost. By giving Wahhabis a free hand over Saudi Arabia's
religious and educational sectors, the royal family brought
about the current showdown. Instead of fostering a liberal
and intellectual class that despises the Wahhabis and that
could have been an important ally against them, the Saudi
regime has, instead, imprisoned those calling for liberal
reform.
Last year, Crown Prince Abdullah brought together Saudi
intellectuals, including women and members of the country's
Shiite minority, to debate much-needed reform as an antidote
to a Wahhabism run amok. However, every discussion of reform
is routinely tempered with the caveat: "It cannot be too
fast." But what is "too fast" when militants kill a BBC
cameraman and critically injure a journalist in broad
daylight as they did earlier this month? What is "too fast"
when car-bombs are killing Saudis and non-Saudis, Muslims
and non-Muslims, alike?
"I
am scared," a Saudi man told me after the Khobar attacks.
"There is no clear vision for where my country is heading.
We want to progress, but we also want to live like the good
Muslims did 1,400 years ago. We want to change, but we
believe that change is the road to hell. We want the people
to have a role in leading the country, but we don't want
democracy. We want to have dialogue with the West, but our
preachers are preaching every Friday that all Westerners, or
non-Muslims, go to hell."
The Muslim world must speak up not only for its religion,
but also for those Saudis caught between the rock of the
royal family and its absolute rule and the hard place of the
Wahhabis and their unforgiving brand of Islam